Peyton Manning, the Colts quarterback, is an awesome player. He's also an all around good person. He's easy-going and is known for his charitable contributions.
He even cleans up pretty well. He looks like a clean-cut, all American guy:

The Patriots quarterback, Tom Brady, is known for leaving his pregnant girlfriend to date a supermodel. And he plays for he Patriots. So, he's clearly pure EVIL.
That is why it is completely outrageous that he is so completely gorgeous:

It just doesn't seem right. He is hot. But, he is evil. So, Manning > Brady.